Black Protest Music …Then and Now

16 Sep

SO…Has the music died, or is there just another chapter? The author of this piece argues it’s come in a circle…

Sounds of Black Protest Then and Now

By William C. Anderson

The sounds Black people make are the brick and mortar of the United States. Literally. The enslaved African’s singing was a driving force for the free labor that built a young nation and put it at the forefront of empires. Historically, Black Americans have been amongst the primary influencers of music culture. The genres that were born of Black misery, triumph, endurance, protest, and expression have changed the way the entire world sounds. But it’s undeniable that many of these songs were and still are shaped by the fatigue of the constant protest that comes with Black existence.

As the son of a Black Southern Pentecostal minister, I’ve had the privilege of sitting among the serene sounds of praise that birthed a nation of noir notes. Just about every genre that has risen to popularity is from the offspring of the Black church. If you listen closely enough, you can hear Black American beginnings on this continent in our cultural songs: one part culture, one part community, one part family, one part fear of fire and brimstone. The tears that beg to line my face when I hear Mary Pickney’s “Down on Me”, Janie Hunters’ “Jonah”, or Mahalia Jackson’s “How I Got Over” retrace Fredrick Douglass’ words:

“I have sometimes thought that the mere hearing of those songs would do more to impress some minds with the horrible character of slavery, than the reading of whole volumes of philosophy on the subject could do….The mere recurrence to those songs, even now, afflicts me; and while I am writing these lines, an expression of feeling has already found its way down my cheek. To those songs I trace my first glimmering conception of the dehumanizing character of slavery.”

It’s important to note that the act of this singing was more than entertainment for plantation overseers or solely expressions of sadness. In its purest form, the slave’s singing was an act of protest. Its beauty and expression transcends the pervasive hell that was the environment that allowed them to be enslaved.

Black existence is an act of rebellion in and of itself, most especially in art. Black people have sung songs amid the persistent onslaught of struggle in the United States, though not exclusively. Enslaved Africans pioneered music like Cumbia, tango, and rumba across the Americas and integrated self-defense and music in Brazil with capoeira. Here in North America, all of the elements of our African diasporic kin’s musical instincts are present in our musical traditions, too.

Since the days of chattel slavery, we’ve heard as our songs have taken different shapes, changed. Jazz’s earliest beginnings in the Congo Square of New Orleans were moments of sanctification, through the allowance of Whites for them to congregate there, to evoke their traditions and make music. Jazz has been consistent in this way over decades. Artists like Nina Simone and Charles Mingus made outspokenness a part of their reputation over the years with songs like “Mississippi Goddam” and “Fables of Faubus”. Miles Davis became the embodiment of Black protest to many through his unwillingness to bend to White standards, insistence that Black women grace his album covers, and even making a tribute to “Black Jack Johnson”. Other imaginative artists like Sun Ra created other, better worlds for Black people through their music. Some artists like Max Roach and Abbey Lincoln infused what they could into Black protests through their art. In the song “Triptych: Prayer/Protest/Peace”, from the classic Black resistance jazz album We Insist, you can hear the waves of emotion Lincoln pours into her vocals. At one point in the song, she arguably sets a shrieking standard for punk rock before the genre officially existed, but not before evoking the symbolic moans of gospel and the blues. The revolutionary nature of Black music always comes back to that starting point.

The blues are Black survival music. While many songs deal with the everyday issues, others from blues’ earliest beginnings up to contemporary times are blatantly political. Three songs about my infamous home state of Alabama come to mind: J.B. Lenoir’s “Alabama”, Lead Belly’s “Scottsboro Boys”, and John Lee Hooker’s “Birmingham Blues”. You can find countless songs about Alabama because it was one of the starting points of the “great migration” Blacks made when they left the South fleeing oppressive violence. Furthermore, it was once the cradle of the civil rights movement and Black activism itself.

Much of the music that defines what most know as Black protest songs are civil rights era protest music. Songs like “We Shall Overcome”, “A Change Is Going to Come”, “We Shall Not Be Moved”, and “Ain’t Gonna Let Nobody Turn Me Round” set the stage for what many millennials like myself would come to know as the movement songs. Documentaries like Eyes on the Prize were filled with these songs as soundtrack to the brutality of White supremacist violence against Black people.

I must admit that seeing these images of Black people singing while being beaten ruthlessly felt self-defeating and depressing as a child. The eternal words of Malcolm X, “stop singing and start swinging,” come to mind. Though there should not be any diminishing of the importance of any particular type of protest music, the current Black generation has moved toward a more confrontational approach….Read the rest of this outstanding piece here


Posted by on September 16, 2015 in Music, From Way Back When to Now


Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

5 responses to “Black Protest Music …Then and Now

  1. Steve

    September 17, 2015 at 2:16 PM


    Pre-Internet, and Pre-cable, we only had 3 or 4 channels to choose from, and only a handful of radio stations to listen to, Now-a-days, we get our new and entertainment from so many sources (many of them unreliable), that we miss-out on really good music, the stuff that actually means something. Personally, I’ll take Lalah Hathaway (both entertainment value and content) over Beyonce any day.

    I stumbled
    upon this brother, Sam Dew:

    Very poetic and powerful IMHO and fits with the sentiment of the article.


    • btx3

      September 17, 2015 at 3:15 PM

      Yeah, that does fit. Sam Dew has one high, beautiful voice. Guy has some chops!

      I’ve got Sirius in my car. It has improved over what it was before merging with XM – but it’s still pretty bad in terms of selection of music, and is pretty much formatted in a “Top 40” format where a few songs get the rotation. The most disturbing thing to me is that the DJs know so little about the music, and it’s history, often playing covers instead of the original groups.


      • Steve

        September 17, 2015 at 5:00 PM

        Here in Detroit, we used to have a radio station called WJZZ. Those DJ’s really knew their musical history, and NEVER relied on Top 40 for their musical selections. Sure, much of what they played was Jazz, but they strayed into R&B, Blues, etc. I discovered so many artists back then… but no more.

        Unfortunately, we must do our own research and music discovery today. is “people-based” internet radio and there are good stations that aren’t restricted to Top 40 – Liquid Soul Elements out of Atlanta is my favorite. They play Jazz, R&B, Jazz, Gospel – and they pull it off.

        I had satellite radio before Smart Phones became popular, but got rid of it – my iphone does so much more in terms of content.


      • btx3

        September 17, 2015 at 6:11 PM

        Sirius isn’t quite as bad as “Top 40” was – but when they play a cover instead of the original, and don’t seem to know the difference – it kind of pisses me off. Especially the older stuff, where black artists were ripped off and never paid.

        Dug out my old album collection and started playing it again a few months back. I’ve got a small collection of 78s going back to the 20’s, and probably about 1000 LPs (I worked for a station for a while, so I got the extras free for a year). Every so often I will check out the local used album shop for a copy of something I missed back in the day.

        Bet you didn’t know that Vinyl is the only segment of Album sales which is growing, and accounts for 9% of everything sold now.

        The young folks are buying Albums, old turntables, and systems capable of handling them like crazy. They are even buying tube amps as fast as the appear on Craigs List! At least their hearing wasn’t totally burned out by Ipods!


  2. Steve

    September 17, 2015 at 5:03 PM

    Also, it’s good to see younger folks like Sam Dew and Janelle Monae pick up the baton.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: